Artisan Bakery · Yukon, Oklahoma

Every cupcake tells a story —
let yours be unforgettable.

Handcrafted with real butter, premium vanilla, and a whole lot of heart. From your morning pick-me-up to the centerpiece of your celebration — ButterSweet makes every moment sweeter.

Order Now See Today's Flavors
Fresh Baked Daily
Local Yukon, OK
Custom Orders Welcome
Beautifully decorated artisan cupcakes on a marble surface
Close-up of a frosted cupcake with gold sprinkles
Handcrafted Daily
Warm bakery interior with cupcake display case
Scroll to explore

Today's Selection

Flavors Worth
Saving Room For

Rotating daily — because the best things are made fresh, not mass-produced.

Classic vanilla cupcake with buttercream swirl

Classic Vanilla Bean

Madagascar vanilla in a tender crumb, swirled with our signature buttercream.

Bestseller
Rich chocolate cupcake with ganache topping

Dark Chocolate Ganache

Double chocolate cake drowned in velvety dark chocolate ganache.

Rich
Strawberry cupcake with cream cheese frosting

Strawberry Blush

Fresh strawberry cake with a whisper of cream cheese frosting.

Seasonal
Red velvet cupcake with cream cheese frosting

Red Velvet Dream

Southern-style red velvet with tangy cream cheese swirl.

Fan Favorite
Lemon cupcake with lemon buttercream and zest

Lemon Zest & Honey

Bright lemon cake sweetened with real honey and topped with citrus buttercream.

Light
Salted caramel cupcake with caramel drizzle

Salted Caramel Swirl

Brown butter cake with house-made caramel and a flaky sea salt finish.

New

Flavors rotate daily. Call ahead or visit us for today's full lineup.

Baker decorating cupcakes in a warm kitchen
Cupcakes in a beautiful gift box ready for pickup
Est. Yukon, OK

Our Story

Baked Like
It Used to Be

ButterSweet Cupcakes was born from a simple belief: that a cupcake should taste like something made with care — real ingredients, real flavor, real love. No shortcuts, no preservatives, no compromises.

Located right here in Yukon, we bake small batches every morning so every cupcake that leaves our kitchen is as fresh as it gets. Whether you're grabbing a treat for yourself or ordering a dozen for a celebration, we put the same attention into every single one.

Real Ingredients

Real butter, farm eggs, pure vanilla — never artificial.

Baked Fresh Daily

Small batches every morning — never day-old.

Made with Love

Every cupcake is decorated by hand, with pride.

Place Your Order

Ready to
Make It Sweet?

Whether it's a dozen for the office, a custom tier for a wedding, or just because — we'd love to make your order special. Call us, send an email, or stop by the shop.

Call Us (405) 265-4994
Email tiffany@tastybatter.com
Assorted cupcakes arranged for a celebration

Visit Us

Find
ButterSweet

Address 817 S Mustang Rd # 6768
Yukon, OK 73099

Send Us a Message

Have a question or want to place a custom order? We'll get back to you within 24 hours.

Message Sent!

Thanks for reaching out — we'll get back to you soon. In the meantime, feel free to give us a call!

Is this your business? This is my business